Written by SpoiledIdeas, a healthcare marketing agency in Mumbai.
The short version: six checks, and how we answer them
| Check | Why it matters | SpoiledIdeas' answer |
|---|---|---|
| NMC 2026 compliance, clause by clause | The doctor, not the agency, carries the penalty (clause 4.4) | Our NMC guide and free checklist |
| Healthcare-only portfolio | General agencies learn the rules on your registration | 20 hospital, clinic and doctor clients |
| Hospital clients you can recognise | Proof that the work holds up at hospital scale | Samata Hospital, Fortis Hospital, Wadia Hospitals, HCG (clients) |
| Video, podcasts and PR in-house | Patient education and press now drive search and AI answers | Doctors on The Ranveer Show and Figuring Out, hospital films |
| Verifiable reviews | Reviews you can read on Google, not on the agency's own site | 4.9 on Google from 43 reviews |
| Years in business | Agencies come and go; your website and listings must outlast them | Since 2014, office in Ghatkopar West (about) |
A disclosure first
SpoiledIdeas is a healthcare marketing agency in Ghatkopar West. We wrote this checklist, and we would like you to hire us. We have tried to write the checks you should apply to any agency, including us, and nothing here requires choosing SpoiledIdeas. If an agency, us included, fails a check, ask why before you sign.
Why choosing carefully matters more since October 2026
The NMC's guidelines of 6 Oct 2026 say that publishing through an agency does not absolve a doctor or hospital of responsibility for content it authorised, commissioned or knowingly permitted (clause 4.4). Penalties for doctors run from a warning and ethics training up to suspension and, for repeated violations, removal from the register for 1 to 3 years (clause 10.1). Your agency's mistakes land on your registration, not theirs.
The 15 checks
Money and contract
- Fixed fees only. The agency charges a fixed monthly retainer or a fixed project fee. Walk away from any offer priced per lead, per enquiry, per call, per booking or per patient: NMC clauses 8.1(vii) and 8.1(viii) bar these arrangements for doctors, and you carry the risk.
- Ad spend kept separate. Money for Google or Meta ads is billed by the platform to your account. The agency's fee is shown separately, so you know what you pay for work and what for media.
- A written scope per line. The proposal lists deliverables month by month: pages, posts, videos, reports. Vague "digital growth packages" are hard to hold anyone to.
- A fair exit. The contract states the notice period and what happens to your content and accounts if you leave.
Ownership and data
- You own every account. Domain, website, hosting, Google Business Profile, Google Ads, Meta Business, analytics and social profiles are in your name, with the agency added as a manager. If the agency insists on owning them, you are renting your own reputation.
- Consent on every form. Enquiry forms carry a consent line and a link to a privacy policy. The IT (SPDI) Rules 2011 already require written consent before collecting health information, and the DPDP Act 2023 duties start on 13-14 May 2027.
- No patient lists in ad platforms. The agency does not upload patient data for remarketing or lookalike audiences without lawful consent, and does not target under-18s.
Compliance
- They know the rules by clause. Ask: "Can I ask patients for Google reviews? Can we post before/after photos? Can you charge me per lead?" A good agency answers with clause numbers (Explanation V, 8.1(v), 8.1(viii)) and a safe alternative, not a shrug. Our NMC guide lists the answers.
- A written approval process. Every asset is checked against the NMC rules and the ASCI Code before it goes out, and you or your nominated approver signs off. Ask to see their checklist; ours is public as a free tool.
- No banned tactics on the menu. Patient testimonials, before/after galleries, influencer endorsements of a doctor, "free consultation" offers, bought reviews or followers, and AI-generated doctors or patients should not appear in the proposal. If they do, the agency has not read the rules.
- Disclosures built in. Templates for doctor posts include the doctor's name, qualifications and SMR/NMR registration number (Explanation III), and hospital posts name the doctors with the same details (Explanation IV).
Proof
- No superlatives about themselves. An agency that calls itself the city's greatest, number one or most trusted without a published, independent method is showing you how it will write your copy. ASCI requires claims to be substantiated, and NMC clause 8.1(ix) applies the same test to your ads.
- Reviews you can check, with a date. A rating should come with its source and date and a link you can open, for example "4.9 on Google from 43 reviews". Undated star badges or widget counts that do not match the source are a warning sign.
- Case studies with names, dates and sources. Real work shows the client (named with permission, or clearly anonymised), the period, the starting point, what was done and where each number came from. Ask to speak to one client in your specialty.
Fit
- They have done your kind of work. A hospital needs an agency that can handle departments, a doctor directory, several Google listings and many approvers. A solo clinic needs one that will keep things factual and small. Ask for examples at your scale, in your part of Mumbai, Thane or Navi Mumbai.
Questions to ask on the first call
| Ask | A good answer sounds like |
|---|---|
| How do you charge? | "A fixed monthly fee for this list of deliverables; ad spend is paid by you to Google." |
| Who owns the accounts? | "You do. We are added as managers and removed when we leave." |
| Can you get us more Google reviews? | "We can fix your listing and set an institution-level, neutral review policy. The doctor should not ask patients." |
| What results can you promise? | "None as a promise. Here is what we will measure, and here is what happened for a client like you, with dates." |
| Who checks content against the NMC rules? | "This person, using this checklist, before you approve it." |
Red flags
- Payment linked to leads, calls or patients.
- Promised rankings ("page one in 30 days") or promised patient numbers.
- Packages of followers, likes or reviews.
- Proposals built on testimonials, before/after content, influencer endorsements or discount campaigns.
- Reluctance to put accounts in your name.
- Claims you cannot check: undated ratings, unnamed results, awards without the awarding body and date.
How SpoiledIdeas answers these checks
We charge fixed retainers or project fees and never per lead or patient, keep ad spend billed to your account, put every account in your name, check every asset against the NMC rules before you approve it, and show our case studies with their sources. Our Google rating is shown with its date on our reviews page. If you want an outside view of who else Google and AI assistants show for these searches, see our fair comparison of Mumbai agencies, which discloses our interest the same way this page does.
Frequently asked questions
How it charges. Under NMC clauses 8.1(vii) and 8.1(viii), a doctor may not pay an agency per lead or per patient, so insist on a fixed retainer or project fee. The risk of a per-lead deal falls on the doctor's registration, not the agency.
Yes. Clause 4.4 of the 6 Oct 2026 guidelines says using an agency, platform or influencer does not absolve the doctor or hospital of responsibility for content it authorised, commissioned or knowingly permitted.
No. Keep every account in your name and add the agency as a manager. That way you keep your reviews, history and data if you change agencies.
No honest agency can, because rankings depend on Google and on competitors. Ask instead what will be measured and see dated results from similar clients.
It is a warning sign. ASCI requires claims to be substantiated, and an agency comfortable with unverifiable superlatives about itself may write the same kind of claims for you, which NMC clause 8.1(ix) restricts.
It helps for shoots, launches and meetings, but expertise in healthcare rules and your specialty matters more. Ask for examples at your scale and in your specialty.
You shouldn't take it on trust. Every check here can be verified against the NMC guidelines, Google's rules or the ASCI Code, and we have disclosed that we wrote it.
Related pages
- Top healthcare marketing agencies in Mumbai (2026): a fair comparison
- NMC Advertising Guidelines 2026 for Doctors and Hospitals: Allowed, Banned, Penalties
- How much does healthcare marketing cost in Mumbai?
- NMC Ad Compliance Checklist for Doctors and Hospitals
- Healthcare Marketing Case Studies
- About SpoiledIdeas: a Mumbai healthcare marketing agency since 2014